David Sholtz holds a distinguished educational background, graduating from Boys High School and attending Yale University, where he was a member of the Acacia fraternity. He earned a law degree from Stetson University Law School in 1914. Sholtz began his career as a Florida lawyer, leveraging the state's diploma privilege to practice without taking the bar examination. Throughout his career, he demonstrated leadership in various capacities, including significant roles within Freemasonry, the Elks, and the Shriners. His personal life reflects a commitment to family and community involvement, marked by his marriage and membership in civic organizations.

David Sholtz combines a traditionalist approach to legal practice with a progressive stance on diploma privilege, suggesting a selective alignment with modern standards. His active engagement in fraternal organizations like the Freemasons, Elks, and Shriners indicates a strong commitment to community and social networks, which he leverages in his political and legal career. Sholtz’s personal warmth and discretion hint at a nuanced public persona, balancing visibility with a preference for privacy.